M.Sc (master of science) courses in medical
subjects including anatomy, physiology, biochemistry, microbiology
and pharmacology are offered by Kasturba Medical College (Manipal
and Mangalore). These are the only two colleges in Karnataka that
offer these courses. Similar courses are offered by Maharashtra,
Kerala, Tamilnadu and Kerala universities too. Every year several
students from Karnataka and outside take admission in these two
colleges. Not many are aware of its value and utility. The fee
structure has been constantly on the rise.
This article shall concentrate only on M.Sc in medical
microbiology. Even though this is a postgraduate course, it
is not considered a PG course by (Medical Council of India (MCI).
Typically, any PG course lasts only for two years but medical M.Sc
courses are offered for three years. The first year is dedicated
entirely to learning medical subjects like human anatomy, physiology and
biochemistry just the way first year MBBS students do. The only
difference lies in Anatomy where brain and limbs are not included
in the syllabus. After the student clears the first year, he/she
can then proceed to the subject of specialty, which lasts for
additional two
years.
During the subsequent two years of study, the student
has to take up 2-3 internal assessment examination and undertake a
dissertation. The course, curriculum and system of examination are
exactly similar to that of MD course. The only difference
between M.Sc and MD course is the duration, MD student get three
years to study the same portion. During the course the student has
to present subject and culture seminars besides undertaking a
research work leading to submission of dissertation. The
dissertation part has unfortunately been abolished in certain
institutions. At the end of
two years, a final examination would be held that consists of
theory and practical examination. Practical examination is held
for three days and the examiner panel consists of internal as well as
external examiners. The pattern of examination is same that of MD
examination. Since Manipal University is a deemed one, answer
booklets are evaluated in the same university. The successful
candidate is then awarded a masters degree in medical microbiology
and a certificate is given to this effect at convocation.
People holding this medical degree are commonly referred as
"non-medicos".
The options these students have next is
limited. Unreserved candidates securing 60% or above and reserved
candidates with 55% can pursue higher education by undertaking
doctoral study (PhD). Clearance of UGC CSIR/NET and Gate exams
with good results would be added benefit as they would be given
preference. Such candidates are eligible for regular
scholarship. A student can pursue PhD in any
institution or university in Karnataka or outside provided it is
recognized by MCI. Obtaining a PhD in non-medical universities
will not be recognized by MCI. In Karnataka, PhD can be sought at
following places:
Rajiv Gandhi Univesity of Health Sciences, NIMHANS
Manipal University and several deemed universities are offering
PhD courses.
Those not interested in PhD or unable to
purse may opt for other studies such as bioinformatics, clinical
research, medical transcription, biotechnology, genetics etc. Other
less desirable study options includes computer courses. Students
not interested in further studies can find employment in
diagnostic laboratories, call centers, pharmaceutical companies or
biotech companies. If you are lucky you could land a technician
job at any hospital in Gulf. Or worse, one can join a medical
college as teacher. Several medical colleges are no longer
entertaining "non-medicos" for teaching posts. The MCI
has notified that non-medicos may be employed in medical college
if all attempts at finding MDs fail and the institution has to
furnish proof of their attempts. The appointment of non-medicos
now require prior approval from MCI.
Scope of M.Sc post
graduates joining medical
colleges as faculty: In simple words, there is no scope at all.
There was a time when there were no takers for para-clinical
subjects like microbiology by MBBS graduates, hence the M.Sc degree
holders were then in demand. Now almost every college has full
admission to MD microbiology. Each year 20-30 MD students pass out
of medical colleges from Karnataka alone and the number of M.Sc students from both the
KMC colleges too is almost the same. With so many MD degree holders
around, the scope for M.Sc degree holders is scarce. Many
institutions are not appointing M.Sc degree holders these days.
Some colleges appoint them as tutors or demonstrators and not even as
lecturers. Even if a M.Sc degree holder is appointed
as lecturer, he/she is entitled to promotion as Assistant
professor after three years, which is wrongly and unjustly denied
in several institutions. The pay package in private institutions
too may vary with the degree, where M.Sc degree holders may be
underpaid. MCI does not recommend promoting M.Sc faculty above the
post of Asst. Prof. without a medical PhD. In simple words, a M.Sc
faculty can not expect any growth in medical college without a
PhD. The post graduate course (M.Sc) is not considered as a
post-graduate course by MCI at all. The discrimination between
M.Sc and MD degree holders is intense and many times unhealthy. In
simple words, M.Sc holders have no place in a medical world. A M.Sc degree holder is branded as "non-medico" and is looked down upon in many
cases.
Here are the differences
between M.Sc and MD faculty.
| Issue |
MD |
M.Sc (without PhD) |
Monetary benefits |
| Assistant Professor designation |
Immediately or after 3 years of MD |
Generally denied (even after a decade) |
Yes |
| Further promotion |
Natural progression |
No further promotion |
Yes |
| Medical Internal/External examiners |
Eligible |
Eligibility denied |
Yes |
| Dental Internal/ External examiners |
Eligible |
Eligibility denied |
Yes |
| Question paper setting |
Eligible |
Eligibility denied |
Yes |
| Paper evaluation (Nursing) |
Eligible |
Eligibility denied |
Yes |
| Room superintendent post |
Eligible |
Eligibility denied |
Yes |
| Deputation for govt. sponsored programmes |
Eligible |
Eligibility denied |
Not known |
| Consideration for sponsored projects |
Eligible |
Eligibility denied |
Yes |
| Setting internal assessment question
papers |
Eligible |
Eligibility denied |
No |
| Registration for IAMM |
Immediately after PG |
Only after 3 years |
No |
| Professional practice (clinical &
diagnostic) |
Eligible |
Little scope; since not considered eligible by many |
Yes |
| Recognition status |
medical post-graduate |
"non-medical" |
No |
|
|
|
The discriminations and eligibilities vary from institution to
institution and may not be exactly as mentioned above. It is also
possible that some of the MSc degree holders are well off in some
cases, but such conditions are rare. One may join a medical
institution but must be prepared for denial of many opportunities
as well as dignity. None of your merits will ever be considered. You may be a
gold-medalist in MSc, but you will still be of no match to a MD
holder who took years to pass. Medical colleges are for doctors,
keep away from them if your dignity and growth is of any
importance to you.Even though the course & curriculum is
identical, medical MSc is never considered equivalent to MD degree.
Strangely enough, one is eligible to teach medical students but
not eligible to examine them or set question paper; a principle
that does not make sense. There is tremendous opposition to
welfare of MSc's in medical institutions. MSc degree holders are
not supposed to excel in income or academics and every opportunity
to excel might be sabotaged. People demand lesser salaries to MSc
degree holders since they can't accept "non-medicos" getting same
remuneration. The reasons why there is so much discrimination is
more than what meets the eye. Medical MSc degree holders are
subjected to what can be called "academic apartheid".
A similar article is available in this
blog,
visitors may comment there.
Summary this article:
1) Do not take up MSc in any of the medical subjects (Anatomy,
Physiology, Biochemistry, Microbiology, Pharmacology)
2) If you happened to do just that, don't stop at that. Pursue till
you get a medical PhD. A non-medical PhD is useless in medical
colleges.
3) No matter what, don't take up job in medical college or
hospitals. Keep away from medical institutions.
4) MSc in medical subjects are respected in certain other
developed countries, people here don't. If possible, fly
abroad. |